20 Years After Sachar Committee: Indian Muslims Under Hindutva Project, Political Marginalisation, SIR and Bulldozer Raj
Nawab Uddin
TWENTY years ago, on November 17, 2006, the high level committee constituted under the leadership of Justice Rajendra Sachar submitted its report to the then UPA government. The report held up a mirror before the Indian Republic, clearly reflecting the actual condition of Indian Muslims even after six decades of independence. It was not merely a compilation of statistics but a document revealing the deep gap between the claims of Indian democracy and social reality. The report showed that the country’s largest minority community lagged behind in almost every measure of education, employment, government jobs, banking facilities, political representation, and social development.
At the time, the central issue of debate was the social and economic backwardness of Muslims. But today, more than two decades later, this question has become far broader and more serious. The issue is no longer limited to backwardness; it is now also linked to insecurity, communal polarisation, political marginalisation, mob violence, bulldozer politics, questions of citizenship, the crisis of protecting one’s status as a voter, and the limits imposed on democratic rights. Therefore, this journey is not merely the story of one community but also a story of the changing direction of Indian democracy.
The Sachar Committee found that Muslims, who constituted approximately 13.4 per cent of India’s population, accounted for only around 5 per cent of government jobs. Their representation in the Indian Administrative Service was approximately 3 per cent, less than 2 per cent in the Indian Foreign Service, and around 3 per cent in the security forces. The report also highlighted that education, healthcare, banking, and basic facilities in Muslim-concentrated areas were weaker than the national average. In many cases, the socio-economic condition of Muslims was found to be comparable to, or even worse than, that of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
Following the Sachar Committee Report, the then UPA government, which was supported from outside by the Left parties, took several steps. Development programmes were launched for Muslim-concentrated districts, scholarships were increased, and special emphasis was placed on education and skill development. Schemes such as the Maulana Azad educational scholarships became an important source of support for Muslim students during this period. Alongside these measures, efforts were also made to develop infrastructure in minority-concentrated areas.
However, after the BJP came to power in 2014, major changes began to take place in these policies and initiatives. The government started implementing the RSS’s Hindutva project in a highly organised manner. Existing schemes were weakened or their direction changed. The impact was first visible in the fields of education and scholarships, where the reach and effectiveness of several special schemes designed for minority students gradually became limited. Schemes such as the Maulana Azad educational scholarships were discontinued, directly affecting the education of poor Muslim students.
Simultaneously, attacks on democratic rights and voices of protest also increased. Several students, social activists, and intellectuals who raised their voices against government policies faced the use of stringent laws. They were wrongly kept in jail for years. Serious questions have repeatedly been raised about the use of laws such as the UAPA. Umar Khalid, Sharjeel Imam, Khalid Saifi, Gulfisha Fatima, Safoora Zargar, Meeran Haidar, Dr Kafeel Khan and several others are among those who have remained in jail for long periods or have been entangled in legal proceedings. As a result, expressing dissent and opposition has become more difficult than before. The percentage of Muslims among the total prisoners in Indian jails is far higher than their proportion in the population. Keeping most prisoners behind bars for years without trial and without their charges being proven has become a common occurrence.
During the same period, Muslim minority educational institutions have also remained under constant scrutiny. Questions have repeatedly been raised about the minority character and rights of institutions such as Jamia Millia Islamia and Aligarh Muslim University. Obstacles have also emerged from time to time concerning their administrative structures, expansion, and academic freedom. The proposed expansion centres of Aligarh Muslim University in Kerala and Bengal, envisaged in the spirit of the Sachar Committee Report, have effectively come to a halt. Everyone has witnessed the case involving the closure of the Mata Vaishno Devi Medical College in Jammu. Every possible effort has been made to destroy Jauhar University in Rampur. Secondary educational institutions in different states are facing various kinds of new regulations.
Alongside this, a new atmosphere has emerged around madrasas, an important component of Muslim education. The Sachar Committee Report shattered the myth that most Muslim children study in madrasas. According to the report, only approximately 4 per cent of Muslim children received their education in madrasas, yet in recent years, incidents of bulldozer action against madrasas, their closure, or their demolition have been reported in several places. This has increased the sense of insecurity within the Muslim education system. At the same time, Muslim students pursuing modern education have also faced social and administrative obstacles in several places, affecting the educational environment.
The Sachar Committee had also reported that Muslim political representation was considerably lower than their proportion in the population. Even today, their participation in Parliament and state legislatures reflects the same inequality. The failure of major political parties to give tickets to Muslim candidates in several states has further deepened this situation. In the 2024 General Elections, only one Muslim candidate stood from the BJP in the entire country.
Under the same BJP government, deliberate attempts have been made not only to eliminate their political representation but also to attack their voting rights as voters. Under the guise of SIR, their votes have been selectively deleted and they have been stripped of their constitutional right to vote. In West Bengal, lakhs of people are standing in queues before tribunals. Large numbers of votes have also been deleted in other states, and where this has not been possible, attempts are being made to invalidate their votes through conspiracies involving the misuse of administrative machinery. The manner in which more than 13,000 votes, most of them belonging to Muslims, in the electoral roll of Pilibhit Sadar Assembly constituency in Uttar Pradesh were reportedly rendered invalid using the same EPIC number points towards the communal happenings.
Amendments were also made to the Waqf law, enabling Waqf properties to be misappropriated heavily. Muslim dargahs, khanqahs, and mosques were increasingly targeted and bulldozers were used, completely disregarding the law. It is not hidden anymore that under bulldozer rule every Muslim property has been targeted by the Sangh and the BJP.
The question that arises now is whether all this is merely the result of separate administrative or political decisions, or whether a long-term ideological vendetta is also at work behind these developments. These events cannot be viewed in isolation. Behind all of this lies the ideological stream of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), whose political wing is the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Its objective - centered on Hindutva extremism and “Hindu Rashtra” - is the redefinition of India’s identity on the basis of religion and culture. Under this thinking, citizenship becomes rooted in cultural identity rather than equal rights, leading minority communities such as Muslims to be viewed, at times, as different, suspicious and sub-citizens rather than as equals.
At the same time, caste and class structures make this situation even more complex, with Dalits, backward classes, and Muslims being affected at different levels.
However, the question of Muslims is not merely religious or communal. It is also a profound economic question. Most Muslims are labourers, small farmers, artisans, and workers in the unorganised sector. The impact of unemployment, inflation, and privatisation policies also falls directly upon them.
One major political consequence of communal polarisation is that it diverts society away from its real economic and social issues. When the discussion should centre on unemployment, poverty, and inequality, the debate becomes entangled in questions of Hindu-Muslim and shamshan-kabristan rhetoric.
Twenty years later, what is needed once again is not a new committee but the political will to implement the core spirit of the Sachar Committee. Issues such as education, employment, healthcare, banking, and political representation must be brought to the centre of public debate. Alongside protecting their voting rights, safeguarding democracy, the Constitution, and civil rights is equally essential.
The future of Indian Muslims cannot be secured in isolation. Their progress is linked to the collective struggles of India’s workers, farmers, Dalits, Adivasis, and women. The journey from the Sachar Committee Report to SIR and bulldozer politics brings us to the realisation that if the principles of equality, secularism, and social justice are weakened in a democracy, democracy is reduced to nothing more than an electoral process.
The greatest challenge before India today is to uphold and strengthen the core values of its Constitution, secularism, and social justice so that every citizen can enjoy equality, dignity, and opportunity.


