Economy is in Virtual Recession: Modi Government in Total Denial
ON the first day of the winter session of Parliament, the finance minister has stated that though the economy has slowed down, it is well on the target of reaching a $5 trillion economy by 2025. At the current rates of growth, notwithstanding all the data fudging and efforts to show the economy is recovering, the reality is that India’s growth rate is declining steadily and dangerously.
The NCAER has now projected the current growth rate at below 5 per cent(4.9 per cent). The PTI had filed a story on October 31 reporting a US think tank (Centre for Global Development) assessment that “India’s growth is in barely positive territory”. Other top institutions have also similarly rated India’s growth rate projections at below 5 per cent. The ICRA rating agency places it at 4.7 per cent. The State Bank of India pecks it at 4.2 per cent.
A closer look at key parameters of the Indian economy shows that this declining growth rate has severely impacted on people’s welfare pushing up unemployment and poverty across the board.
Industry: Ministry of commerce and industry has conceded that the growth in eight core sectors of the economy has slipped from 7.3 per cent in July 2018 to 2.1 per cent in July 2019. Manufacturing sector growth dipped from 6.9 per cent in June 2018 to 1.2 per cent in June 2019. The industrial growth rate has consequently seen a massive fall.
The automobile industry has seen the sharpest decline in 19 years. Nearly 300 dealerships across the country have been closed down with a loss of around two lakh jobs. This industry has registered a decline of 23.55 per cent from 2018 with a drastic fall in vehicle sales. Tractor sales, an indicator of rural demand, saw a fall of 14.1 per cent during April/June 2019 – the highest in recent years.
MSMEs: This sector has seen a layoff of over 35 lakh workers during the past few years. Traders were the hardest hit as they constitute 43 per cent of the job losses, a direct consequence of the demonetisation. The small industry segment saw job losses of 35 per cent, 32 per cent in micro enterprises and 24 per cent in medium enterprises. The credit taken by the MSME units to conduct their businesses saw a massive drop between 50 to 80 per cent. The Modi government’s much tom-tomed Mudra loan scheme aimed at financially supporting the MSMEs, self help groups and village level enterprises saw a whopping rise in non-performing assets which registered a 126 per cent rise between 2018 and 2019.
The MSMEs sector is the largest employment provider in the economy after agriculture. This has now been totally crippled.
The basic cause for this economic recession is the sharp fall in the purchasing capacities amongst the vast majority of the Indian people. As a result of demonetisation and the implementation of the GST, large-scale unemployment is being witnessed in recent years.
The private final consumption expenditure, backbone of India’s GDP, contributing 57 per cent, plummeted to a dismal 3.1 per cent growth in June quarter of 2019 from 7.2 per cent in the March quarter. This is the main reason for this economic decline. All sectors are reporting significantly lower sales including the fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG). This has significantly slowed down in the last one year – Hindustan Lever from 12 to 5 per cent, Dabur India from 21 to 6 per cent, Britannia from 13 to 6 per cent. In a country of chai biskut, the sale of Rs 5 biscuit packets has also plummeted.
Unemployment: The unemployment rate has registered its highest levels in the last half a century. Officially, 1.1 crore jobs were lost in 2018 alone. An estimated 35 lakh jobs were lost due to demonetisation alone (CMIE data).
Every year, at least, 50 lakh youth join the labour market. Despite this, the labour participation in the economy has dropped from 43 per cent in 2004-05 to 36.9 per cent in 2017-18. Rate of droppage for women labour force during this period was from 29.4 per cent to 17.5 per cent.
The achhe din promise was to generate two crore jobs every year. Yet, in 2017-18, 11.56 crores (115.6 million) educated youth in the age group of 15 to 29 were unemployed compared to seven crores (70 million) in 2004-05. In absolute terms, manufacturing jobs fell by a massive 106 lakh during the four-year period from 2011-12 to 2015-16 - 589 lakhs to 483 lakhs.
Falling Real Wages: The real wages for urban workers fell from Rs 226 in 2012-13 to Rs 205 between 2012 and 2018 – a decline of 8.9 per cent. The rural casual workers’ wages that had risen 44.5 per cent before 2012, thanks mainly to the MGNREGA, rose barely by over 6 per cent during 2012-18 due to the abandonment of this programme by the Modi government.
Agriculture: The agricultural distress continues to deepen with its growth rate dropping from an average of 3.37 per cent (2004-14) to average 2.7 per cent (2014-19). Rural wage growth has actually declined to 3.09 per cent in January 2018 from over 6.5 per cent in January 2017. In 2019, there was a further decline.
PM Kisan, designed to provide benefits to 12.5 crore farmers, on the basis of which Modi and BJP reaped significant electoral benefit, was, as expected, virtually abandoned post elections. Till July 15, 2019, only 3.97 crore (32 per cent of the eligible) have received the first instalment. Subsequently, only 3.5 crore farmers have received the second instalment.
DECLINE IN GOVERNMENT REVENUES
The tax collections under this government have declined drastically. The growth of indirect tax revenues slowed down from 21.33 per cent during 2016-17 to 5.8 per cent in 2017-18. Even the service sector contributed 10 per cent less than estimated (mainly due to the contraction of the IT sector). The government had set a target of Rs 13.35 lakh crore for 2019-20 for direct taxes. However, in the first six months, only Rs. 5.5 lakh crores were collected. Another 7.85 lakh crores needs to be collected in the next six months to meet the target! The GST collections registered a 20 per cent fall.
NPA’s percentage of total loans has increased from 3.8 per cent in 2014 to 9.3 per cent in 2018. The write offs of the NPAs rose to almost eight times higher than prior to 2014. The names of the defaulters and fraudsters, whose NPAs have been written off, are not disclosed. The Modi government deliberately shields such fraudsters.
Crony Capitalism: Apart from such direct patronage provided to BJP’s cronies through the NPAs, the Modi government has now embarked on large-scale privatisation to benefit its crony corporates.
PRIVATIZATION OF THE PUBLIC SECTOR
All public sector units have been targeted for privatisation, including the railways, Air India and major enterprises like the MTNL, BSNL, BPCL etc. This will lead to a large-scale retrenchment of jobs adding to the woeful unemployment situation. Importantly, this undermines the backbone of India’s economic sovereignty, which is detrimental for, both, our country and the people’s welfare.
Needless to add, the bulk of the gains that will be made through such large-scale privatisation will accrue to the very same cronies of this government constituting yet another route for the loot of India’s public assets.
DIVERTING PUBLIC MONIES
In order to offset its shortfall in tax collections, the economy’s loot through NPAs that have created an unprecedented crisis for India’s banking sector, this Modi government has siphoned off Rs 1.76 lakh crores from the RBI surplus funds and has pressurised public sector companies like the LIC to divert the money of people’s lifelong savings to bailout public sector banks and contribute to government revenues. The LIC was recently forced to invest Rs 21,000 crores to bailout a debt-ridden Industrial Development Bank of India (IDBI). Dangerously, the government is now proposing to tap into the provident fund, pension and insurance schemes of lakhs of employees. The employees provident fund organisation has a corpus of around Rs 10 lakh crore. If the government taps into these monies, then crores of employees across the country will face ruin with unprecedented insecurities.
INDIA’S INTERNATIONAL STANDING
The Modi government tomtoms that India’s standing in the international economy has never been better since our independence. But the actual data shows the contrary.
Under this government, rupee has become weaker against US dollar, reaching over Rs 74 per dollar in 2018-19. The average growth of FDI since 2014 was 11.1 per cent – a fall from 31.1 per cent in the decade of 2004-14. Between 2014-15 and 2018-19, FDI flows fallen from 23 per cent to 2 per cent.
This is happening, despite all incentives provided by the Modi government to FDI, displaying a lack of confidence in India’s economic volatility. Consequently, India’s global ratings have seen a sharp downgrading. In November 2017, international global rating agencies upgraded India’s ratings. In the two year since Moodys has downgraded India’s ratings thrice.
Despite the fall in the rupee value, India’s exports, which should have normally gained, as they have now become cheaper compared to the US dollar, have actually dropped. The pre-2014 export growth rate of 18.4 per cent has now come down to 0.89 per cent. Between 2018 and 2019, exports of readymade garments declined by minus 9.18 per cent, chemicals by minus 8.17 per cent and engineering by minus 2.65 per cent.
THE WAY OUT
This economic recession has been caused due to a sharp decline in the purchasing capacities of the vast majority of our people. The answer to turn around the economy lies in providing people the capacity to purchase, thus increasing the levels of domestic demand which may lead to a revival of closed factories. The Modi government has announced a package in two instalments of Rs 2.15 lakh crores providing further tax cuts and benefits to the corporates with the hope that they will increase their investments. Increased investments cannot revive the economy unless people have the capacity to buy what is produced by such new investments. It is precisely this contracting people’s purchasing power that is going to get further exacerbated by the government’s so-called “solutions”.
Instead, if this-Rs 2.15 lakh crores were used for enlarging public investments to build our much-needed infrastructure, social and economic, this would have resulted in the creation of lakhs of new jobs providing employment to our distressed youth. Once they start spending their earnings, the domestic demand would have risen providing the required kickstart for an economic turnaround. On the contrary, cruelly, the government has turned back two out of the 13 crores who applied for work under the MGNREGA.
However, this Modi government in its urge to provide greater avenues for profit-maximisation to foreign and domestic corporates is providing them with concessions while further pushing the vast majority of our people into languishing misery.
It is clear that in the light of this economic recession, the only way to force the Modi government to adopt the course that we have suggested above is through intensified popular struggles. The forthcoming all-India industrial strike call given by the Central Trade Unions on January 8, 2020 is an occasion for all those who oppose the current economic policies to forge powerful campaigns and struggles. In the run-up to this strike, popular movements and powerful struggles must be forged, strong enough to force this government to change its policy direction.